By Laura Johnston
Canada’s small to medium enterprises (SMEs) are unprepared for the coming wave of business ownership transfers, which will be driven by the retirement of baby boomer business owners.
Within 10 years, Canada’s SME sector will undergo a transfer of wealth, estimated at $1 trillion to $4 trillion. Yet, as of this year, as many as three-quarters of Canadian SMEs have failed to find buyers.
This highlights the need for public education in succession planning. Typically, small to medium enterprises have been passed to family members or sold to outsiders on an informal basis.
These practices are no longer sustainable. Successful succession requires a structured plan to pass a business from one generation to another. A formal plan maximizes the value of the business, ensures the continuity of jobs and adequately trains successors. It minimizes risk to future employment and economic prosperity.
Caroline Van Hasselt, director of media relations at CIBC, puts it this way:
“Canadian small and medium-sized business owners are putting their companies at risk by not having a succession plan in place, with nearly three-quarters of family-owned businesses failing after just one generation. … Small and medium-sized businesses are the backbone of Canada’s economy. Yet, the vast majority of business owners (80 per cent) who say they have a succession plan admitted in a CIBC poll earlier this year that their plans were, at best, informal, back-of-the-cocktail napkin ideas even though they are counting on selling the business to fund their retirement.”
Statistics Canada defines a small business enterprise by the number of employees it has, as opposed to the revenues it generates. Of the 1,167,978 employer businesses active in Canada in 2015, micro-enterprises (firms with one to four employees) constituted 54.1 per cent, making them the largest SME group.
When businesses with five to nine and 10 to 19 employees are included, they account for 86.2 per cent of employer businesses.
Medium-sized business – those with 101 to 499 employees – make up 13.8 per cent of total SMEs.
SMEs generate 43 per cent of Canada’s economic output. And in 2015, they accounted for $68 billion in exports or 25 per cent of Canada’s total export value.
The SME sector is vital to the Canadian economy, providing more than 90 per cent of Canadian private employment and creating 70 per cent of new jobs.
Consequently, governments, industry leaders and others are being urged to address succession issues.
And a proliferation of consulting and financial services have stepped in to assist in succession planning. Many law, accounting, insurance and investment firms offer specialized succession services that weren’t available five years ago. Universities now include succession studies in their human resources programs. And a broad selection of do-it-yourself succession software packages are on the market.
The size and complexity of the business and the needs of the owner will determine the type of succession services required. Some businesses require little more than valuation and tax services. Others require a wide scope of professional services, such as wealth management and estate planning, and legal and brokerage planning. Consulting services can also search for prospective buyers and facilitate the transfer of ownership.
When most current SME owners inherited or purchased their businesses, there likely weren’t formal succession plans in place. Those owners are unlikely to see the merit in creating one for themselves now.
Many Canadian SME owners started their businesses from scratch, reflecting the desire to build their own ventures. This poses a challenge to sellers, particularly when so many businesses will be put up for sale at the same time over the next decade. It will be a buyers’ market.
While retirement is cited as the biggest reason for exiting the business, the Canadian Federation of Independent Business (CFIB) reports that 11 per cent of respondents to a survey stated that they want to move to another venture. Six per cent gave personal reasons (health concerns, family issues, a desire to cut back on working hours). Only one per cent were exiting for full-time work elsewhere, which is consistent with the entrepreneurial profile of preferred self-employment.
While 70 per cent of SMEs in Canada are family owned and/or operated, just 20 per cent of survey respondents said they intended to sell to family members, partners or employees. Fifty-three per cent said they intended to sell to outsiders.
For owners, succession planning allows them to exit their business under the best possible conditions. It creates a plan of action that maximizes business value and marketability, minimizes legal and tax issues, reduces costly financial mistakes, and provides a framework for a buyer-seller agreement.
In many instances, the process also finds the right investors or buyers for the business, creating a win for everyone.
A structured approach to SME ownership transfer will help ensure business continuity in communities across the country. To do otherwise is to risk employment stability and economic prosperity as baby boomers retire.
Laura Johnston is a business planning and marketing consultant specializing in business writing, business analysis and development, and strategic planning.
The views, opinions and positions expressed by columnists and contributors are the author’s alone. They do not inherently or expressly reflect the views, opinions and/or positions of our publication.